Sep 15 2025 — 04:09 pm

New Grad Reality Check: What Happens When You Say Yes to a Job But Keep Shopping”

By Ellen Raim

Last week, a senior in college asked me with a question that was weighing on her mind. Some of her friends accepted their summer internship offers but were continuing to interview and look for “better” opportunities. Their logic? Employers play games with new college grad applicants, things like ghosting them when they apply, making offers but pushing out start dates or offering very low salaries.  Therefore, they can play the game right back by accepting a job and reneging on the offer if something better comes along.

She asked if this was a good strategy.

I wanted to find out if this was a new trend, so I did some research and also checked in with a handful of recruiters.

Recent data from Veris Insights shows students are reneging on accepted job offers at nearly double the rate of three years ago; it’s up to 6% of all full-time offers in 2024. Other surveys reflect that roughly 70% of Gen Z candidates say they would rescind an offer if something better comes along. In fairness to Gen Z, Gartner and SHRM also report that, after accepting a job, nearly half of candidates at every level remain open to continuing their search or even “ghosting” their employer before the start date. This suggests that this has moved from an occasional occurrence to a more normalized approach.

I understand the frustration behind this thinking. The job market is brutal right now, especially for college students and recent graduates. After months of applications, rejections, and interview cycles, one may feel they need to take whatever comes along. So, when a better opportunity materializes, the temptation to switch feels justified.

But there are risks to doing this that applicants may not have considered.

The Professional World is Smaller Than You Think

The recruiters I mentioned said the biggest miscalculation with this approach is underestimating how interconnected professional networks really are.

They added, those early in their career may believe they’re anonymous in a sea of candidates, but recruiters and hiring managers remember the person who accepted an offer and then backed out. The recruiters I spoke with reacted to my questions with hurt and surprise. They talk to one another, especially within industries or geographic regions, so word may get around.

I was told there are cases where employers stopped participating in university on site recruiting after students reneged on offers. The smaller the industry or local market, the higher the chance something like this will follow you. That person on the hiring team you disappoint today might become the hiring manager you need tomorrow.

There’s No Going Back

Here’s another strategic flaw: when you renege on one job for another there is a possibility you could lose both opportunities. Any offer can evaporate for reasons completely outside your control (budget freezes, hiring manager departures, team restructures, or economic shifts).

While not a routine practice, companies do rescind offers. Once you’ve burned the bridge with the first offer, there’s no reversal mechanism. That company has almost certainly moved to their backup candidate. You can’t simply call and say “actually, never mind, I do want the job.”

Doing This is Not Pain Free for the Employer

The financial and operational impact on employers is significant. According to Indeed and SHRM, companies invest $4,000-$20,000 per hire in recruiting and onboarding costs. In addition, once you accept someone starts:

  • Preparing your workspace or shipping equipment.
  • Ordering hardware and coordinating with IT.
  • Notifying the team and planning your first day (sometimes a full schedule).
  • Setting you up in payroll and, for remote roles, handling state-by-state compliance.

This is real work, time and money wasted. When candidates renege, hiring managers are forced to restart the process, often reaching back out to other candidates who may have already accepted elsewhere.  If that happens, they must repost the position. The recruiter who championed you through the process takes the professional hit of a failed placement. Real people who invested time and energy in bringing you aboard experience both practical disruption and personal disappointment.

This cycle is driving a more transactional environment for everyone, which ultimately damages future candidates who are genuinely looking to build relationships rather than just optimize short-term outcomes.

Better Job Search Strategies

Before making a decision that risks your reputation and maybe your future options, consider these approaches:

Ask for More Decision Time Up Front

Employers expect candidates to be weighing options, especially during peak recruiting season. If you’re in late-stage interviews with multiple companies, explain your situation and request a reasonable time frame to consider offers. Most recruiters will respect a candid, professional request for more time and may even see it as a sign you’re a sought-after candidate.

If one firm is pressuring you for a quick answer, respectfully communicate:
“I want to make a well-informed decision. Would it be possible to have another week to decide?” Not only is this safer for your reputation, it gives you breathing room to make the best choice.

Be Transparent About Ongoing Interviews

Letting employers know you are in the final stages elsewhere can seem risky, but for experienced recruiters, it’s simply a sign of a competitive market. Transparency also helps companies plan and can result in them sweetening their offer or adjusting timelines to accommodate you.

It’s important to distinguish between openness and oversharing. Share enough so that recruiters know your situation but keep it positive and professional.  Don’t say “you’re my second choice.” Say: “I am excited about this role and also considering another offer. I’d like may I have an additional week to let you know as I finalize my decision.”

Build Relationship Capital

Every interaction in your job search builds or depletes your reputation. Acts of professionalism, speaking honestly about timelines, keeping commitments, and saying no early when you know you won’t accept, generate goodwill that will follow you for years.

Recruiters and hiring managers remember candidates who handled decisions well, and your network grows more valuable when built on trust, not convenience. You may even continue to build a trusted relationship with someone on the hiring team with whom you clicked, even after you say no.  Relationship capital can mean future offers, mentoring, or advocacy in rough markets.

If you disengage professionally, you keep doors open with recruiters too. One of the recruiters I reached out to said: “I have often heard: Two years ago I interviewed with you and went with what I thought was my dream job. Things changed; your company was my first call.” If you burn a bridge at the last minute, that option disappears.

Is it Ever Worth the Risk?

I don’t like this strategy, but I can understand why someone might do it if they perceived the quality of the second job was worth the reputational risk. If they were jumping from a small  firm to a global leader, or switching to an entirely different sector, they might feel the career trajectory gain would outweigh the reputational cost. But in my opinion, this scenario is very rare. The more likely situation is more like the one I described above, and it carries reputational harm.

Another Way to Think About This

The instinct to keep looking once you have an offer in hand is completely understandable in this market. But here’s a question worth considering. When leaders treat employee issues as purely transactional and view them as interchangeable, we know those are not people we want to work for. When you renege on a job offer at the last minute, are you operating in that same transactional mindset?  Would you rather try to build the professional relationships and work habits that make you a great leader?

________________________________________________________________________

Sources

Gen Z at Work?
Play the Game is your guide to thriving in your career without compromising who you are.

View on Amazon